Fact-Check Summary
The post levels personal attacks against Jessica Tarlov and claims she spreads falsehoods about Donald Trump’s polling success and policy achievements. Reviewing polling data, Trump’s recent approval ratings range from 46% to 56%, not the 56% to 68% blanket touted. Claims that “I just won an election…in a Landslide by winning all 7 Swing States, and the Popular Vote by millions” are misleading; the 2024 results showed Trump winning the presidency but by narrower margins, and some states remain close in current 2025 polling. Assertions of “ZERO illegal aliens” entering the country last month under Trump are exaggerated; while illegal border crossings have drastically decreased, official CBP data does not confirm a complete elimination. Lastly, ratings data reveal that “The Five” remains Fox News’ highest-rated show, contradicting suggestions that Tarlov damages viewership.
Belief Alignment Analysis
From a democratic values perspective, this post promotes division, attacks dissenting voices, and undermines the principle of free and fair debate. By calling for the removal of a co-host based on political disagreement and personal dislike, it opposes inclusivity and the marketplace of ideas that are essential to a healthy democracy. The insistence that opposition voices are not only wrong but malicious or “a disgrace” further erodes constructive dialogue. Supporting a pluralistic media environment, including diverse viewpoints like Tarlov’s, is vital for an America that belongs to everyone—not just political majorities or outspoken factions.
Opinion
The post reflects a broader trend of intolerance for dissent and factual reinterpretation for partisan purposes. Instead of engaging with differing views on legitimate grounds, it favors personal attacks and sweeping, unverified statements. While critique of media figures is fair game, efforts to silence or expel opposition for expressing contrary evidence undermine the spirit of democracy. A resilient society requires robust, evidence-based debate—not the exclusion of voices that challenge dominant narratives, regardless of political leaning.
TLDR
Trump’s harsh criticism of Jessica Tarlov and claims about polls, ratings, and immigration do not fully align with available facts. “The Five,” including Tarlov, remains top-rated; Trump’s polls are not as overwhelming as implied; and the U.S. border is not entirely sealed. Efforts to silence opposing voices threaten democratic values—constructive, informed debate is key to a free and inclusive America.
Claim: Jessica Tarlov spreads lies about Trump’s poll numbers and achievements, and her presence has damaged Fox News ratings; Trump states he recently achieved historic poll numbers, a landslide election, and zero illegal crossings at the border.
Fact: Tarlov is Fox News’ liberal voice by design, supporting balanced debate. Trump’s approval ratings are high in some polls but range wider than claimed. No rating decline correlates with Tarlov; “The Five” continues to dominate. There’s been a sharp drop in illegal crossings but not “zero.” The 2024 election was won by Trump, but current polls show smaller leads in swing states and the “landslide” language is misleading.
Opinion: Calls to remove Tarlov and silence dissenting opinions are contrary to democratic ideals. Open dialogue and honest disagreement are cornerstones of a free, fair, and inclusive America; personal attacks and misinformation only foster further division and weaken our democracy.