Fact-Check Summary
The claim attributed to Steve Witkoff on Truth Social—”The proof is in the pudding, no one’s shooting at each other. It’s over.”—references the ceasefire that ended the so-called “12 Day War” between Israel and Iran in June 2025. According to available reporting, Witkoff, as a U.S. envoy, did make this statement, and at the time of his comment, the ceasefire was holding. Independent sources confirm the cessation of open hostilities following the agreement brokered by the Trump administration. However, it is important to recognize that although active shooting had stopped, the situation remained fragile, and full resolution of underlying tensions was not achieved immediately.
Belief Alignment Analysis
Promoting the message that “no one’s shooting at each other” as definitive proof that a conflict is over can be both reassuring and misleading. On one hand, acknowledging a cessation of violence is an inherently positive development and aligns with democratic values that prioritize peace, de-escalation, and the protection of civilian life. However, using such a phrase to imply that all issues are resolved might oversimplify the situation—overlooking complex political, social, and humanitarian factors that continue beyond the guns falling silent. Statements that gloss over these nuances risk impeding transparency and informed public debate, both critical tenets of a healthy, inclusive democracy.
Opinion
While Witkoff’s concise remark reflects the visible effect of the ceasefire, responsible leaders and media should emphasize that true, lasting peace depends on addressing root causes and following through on commitments. Declaring “it’s over” too soon can breed complacency and fail to honor ongoing concerns of those affected by the conflict. In a democracy, it is crucial to demand both honesty and depth from public officials, especially in moments of fragile peace. Real patriotism lies not in triumphant speeches, but in persistent, inclusive efforts to secure justice and security for all people, not just temporary lulls in violence.
TLDR
Steve Witkoff’s claim that the conflict is “over” because no one is shooting refers to a real, brokered ceasefire that largely ended immediate hostilities between Israel and Iran. However, while the shooting had stopped, deeper issues remained, and true peace required further work. Cautious optimism—paired with scrutiny and commitment to truth—is vital for democratic resilience and genuine progress.
Claim: Steve Witkoff stated about the Israel-Iran ceasefire, “The proof is in the pudding, no one’s shooting at each other. It’s over.” This suggests the conflict ended with the ceasefire.
Fact: The quoted statement from Witkoff is verified by reporting and taken in the context of the U.S.-brokered ceasefire that halted direct hostilities. At the time of his statement, the ceasefire was holding, but underlying issues and the potential for renewed conflict persisted.
Opinion: A momentary ceasefire should be celebrated as progress, but not confused with comprehensive peace. Honest, transparent communication and ongoing diplomatic effort are vital to fostering a democratic society that values truth and inclusion over triumphal declarations.